Foodie’s Guide to Amarillo

If there is one thing I remember about Amarillo, it is the food. Goodness, I have never had so much Chicken Fried Steak in my entire life. Personally, I don’t think that it is a bad thing, but I’m sure my dietician would beg to differ. And the portions are so deliciously perfect that I have decided to drag you around from eatery to eatery with me. Is that alright? I’m sure you’re hungry after the tour I gave you around the city anyways.

Where to Eat in Amarillo?

Where to Eat in Amarillo? Youngblood's Cafe Entrance.

We start off our foodie outing in Youngblood’s Cafe. Now, I know that the name begs “hipster joint sprawling with teenagers carrying spray paint cans”, but let me assure you that Youngblood bleeds the opposite end of this spectrum. While the main demographic (at least, when I went) looms over fifty, I still fell in love with this charming little place. The cafe is lightly decorated with Lone Star knick-knacks, creating the same personal allure as a Southern family’s private kitchen.

Now, there are two wings to this restaurant. The Western and Eastern wing. The Eastern wing has a handsome brick fireplace, so let’s head in there.

We sit down in light coloured wooden chairs and take a closer look around. Rope loops over nails and a fair mix of black and white posters and bold coloured works can be found plastered on the wall. The food definitely reflects the cozy ambience. Youngblood’s Cafe is famous for it’s homemade-style Chicken Fried Steak, so I highly suggest trying that first.

Where to Eat in Amarillo? Chicken Fried Steak at Youngblood's Cafe.

Doesn’t that look good? Let’s take a bite, shall we? The steak is flawlessly seasoned and seared to perfection. It doesn’t taste like any Chicken Fried Steak we’ve ever had before. Why? Youngblood doesn’t deep fry the steak, like most other restaurants, but rather cleverly grills it in butter, adding a rich twist to this Southern country classic. The dish is served with a side of hash browns. There isn’t anything special regarding the hash browns, but it stands as a time-honoured side with the seven ounce steak. But what seals the breakfast as commendable is the gravy.

Where to Eat in Amarillo? Biscuits and Gravy, because why not?

The white gravy is creamy and served in a side bowl along with some eggs, which you can get cooked any way you like. Naturally, I smothered the gravy all over the steak and devoured it in a not-so-attractive Adam Richman fashion, but granted, when you taste it, you are bound to do the same.

By now, you are probably feeling a little full, but I have one more restaurant to show you. This is perhaps the most famous restaurant in Amarillo, and as we drive down towards it, we can see why. I promise, this will be an interesting experience.

The Big Texan Steak Ranch blends the phrases “go big or go home” and “everything is bigger in Texas” into a unique medley. From the outside, it looks like a runaway circus. The title of the restaurant is written in a garish manner on a sunflower yellow backdrop. The outside panels are the same outrageous yellow with a striped blue. A windmill swirls mechanically in the background. Outside, is an ironic statue of a baby cow (mind you, the statue is at least five times the size of me). If that sounds incongruous and clashing, it is.Where to Eat in Amarillo? Big Texan Steak Ranch.

As we enter, the carnival-like feel doesn’t halt but rather crescendoes. Statues and animal heads are thrown casually in odd locations. We spot Toy Story characters (I have still to figure out how they fit into this restaurant). The restaurant is huge. There are two floors and it is packed for a good reason. Entering the restaurant is like walking into a Disney theme park food stop. The detail, albeit not coherent, is impeccable, but that just adds to the fun. Big Texan Steak Ranch screams family-friendly from every angle. You can take kids there, and I can guarantee you that they will have a great time. But let’s see how the food is first.

We slip into a secluded booth and wait to order. All the waiters and waitresses here wear cowboy hats and have a natural twangy drawl. From our booth, we can see the chefs cooking the dishes. Everything isn’t prepared behind closed doors so it notches up the entertainment value.

Let’s start with an appetizer. I’m going to order some smothered BBQ Steak Fries. The appetizer is a meal in itself. The fries are thick and soft and are mixed in with several layers of cheese and tenderized steak bits. Fresh red onions are sprinkled generously on top, adding a fresh new texture. The fries lack a little in the salt department, but make the perfect pairing with the slightly briny Dill’s pickles that are layered on top.

Where to Eat in Amarillo? Check out these delicious fries at Big Texan Steak Ranch.

Next up, the main course. If you are feeling brave, try the famed 72 oz steak. If you have a Scooby-sized appetite and can eat it within an hour, the steak is free. I think I’ll play it safe right now, and order a sampler of Baby Back Ribs. The waiter scurries over with a dish fresh from the pan (don’t touch it). The ribs are firm and tender. They aren’t seasoned much, which makes for a perfect Barbecue Sauce entry. The Barbecue sauce is powerful – the smoky and sweet taste can be overwhelming on it’s own, but heavenly with the Ribs. Fried onions are served as a side along with light, airy Texas toast. There is an entire bucket (yes, a bucket – no, I’m not joking) of butter situated at each table, so feel free to apply a generous dose on the toast. Since this is just a sampler, let’s add a side dish as well. I’m going with some coleslaw, how about you? The coleslaw is cold and crunchy, as expected, but the mayonnaise vinaigrette runs slightly too watery and tart at first. However, the taste quickly grew on me.

Where to Eat in Amarillo? Looking for places to eat in Amarillo, then head to Big Texan Steak Ranch for some Amazing BBQ ribs.

Are you finished? Good. We head out to the main lobby, and the carnival like feel escalates once again. There is a haunted house inside and a giant armchair that looks like a roadside attraction chucked indoors. Big Texan Steak Ranch should honestly be a bucket list item for everyone. There are somethings that just have to be seen and experienced in person, and this restaurant is one of them. It is so delightfully quirky and Texan, that I ended up loving it. But much like the coleslaw, it had to grow on me a little.

If you have a little room left, there is a range of gelato to try. Just because of the name, I’m choosing the Texas Pecan Sea Salt Caramel. The gelato is dense and the intense flavor is slightly softened by the caramel drizzle and nutty topping. But, I’ll leave you to pick a flavour of your own and roam around for some more time.

Enjoyed this food tour of Amarillo? Did this post help you find out where to eat in Amarillo? Let me know in the comments below! I love to hear from you (seriously).

You Might Also Like

8 Comments

  • Reply
    Amanda Williams
    March 11, 2016 at 9:46 PM

    I wouldn’t have thought of this as a foodie destination, but it looks awesome. You have made me so hungry!

    • Reply
      Anshula
      March 11, 2016 at 9:51 PM

      Mission accomplished 😉 I didn’t think of Amarillo as a foodie destination either at first, but after I ate (read: devoured) the classic country dishes, I fell in love.

  • Reply
    Maria Berneiser Haase
    March 11, 2016 at 11:29 PM

    Hm, I see a road trip coming in my near future. I haven’t been up in the Panhandle yet and I feel like this might be a great spot to see 🙂

    • Reply
      Anshula
      March 11, 2016 at 11:59 PM

      Awesome! Amarillo is a great road trip stop, especially considering it part of Historic Route 66!

  • Reply
    Hung Thai
    March 12, 2016 at 5:29 AM

    Everything is bigger in Texas! Maybe too big? So much food!

    • Reply
      Anshula
      March 12, 2016 at 3:19 PM

      Haha! Nothing is ever too big, except maybe that 72 oz steak 😉

  • Reply
    Claire and Rosemary
    March 13, 2016 at 3:29 AM

    A 72oz steak, wow!! Would not have thought of Amarillo as a foodie town, but you’ve given me reason to reconsider. Cheers!

    • Reply
      Anshula
      March 13, 2016 at 3:15 PM

      Cheers! Amarillo doesn’t sound like a foodie destination at first, but if you are looking for Chicken Fried Steak…then I haven’t tasted better elsewhere 🙂

    Leave a Reply